Trump and Vance Scold Zelensky in Blowup

Visit abruptly ends, imperiling a deal for peace

Hey, friends. For those of you who are new here, I read the top story in the New York Times every morning so that you don’t have to. If you were forwarded this, you can subscribe here. I’m also doing a five-minute video version of this, each morning at 9 a.m. if you’d like to follow me on LinkedIn (you can always watch the recording later).

Apologies to those of you who were hoping for a quiet weekend 🤦🏻‍♂️

This morning’s papers and broader media are dominated by the extraordinary blowup in the Oval Office yesterday. I’ve been texting back and forth with friends around the world (okay, mainly in my native England lol) this morning about the news. The headline is that Donald Trump appears to be doing Vladimir Putin’s propaganda bidding on the global stage, with remarkable lack of restraint and in a way that makes him look totally out of his depth. If you’re talking to your friends about the news, and I would urge you to, please do reflect on the unprecedented nature of all this. It is particularly important, I think, that we don’t just bury our heads in the sand because it’s so depressing.

Peter Baker does his best to report on it with restraint:

In a fiery public confrontation unlike any seen between an American president and foreign leader in modern times, Mr. Trump and Mr. Vance castigated Mr. Zelensky for not being grateful enough for U.S. support in Ukraine’s war with Russia, and sought to strong-arm him into making a peace deal on whatever terms the Americans dictated.

With his voice raised and temper flaring, Mr. Trump threatened to abandon Ukraine altogether if Mr. Zelensky did not go along. After journalists left the Oval Office, Mr. Trump canceled the rest of the visit, including a planned joint news conference and signing ceremony for a deal on rare minerals, and U.S. officials told the Ukrainians to leave. A grim-faced Mr. Zelensky strode out, climbed into a waiting black sport utility vehicle and departed the White House grounds.

“I have determined that President Zelenskyy is not ready for Peace if America is involved, because he feels our involvement gives him a big advantage in negotiations,” Mr. Trump wrote on social media. “I don’t want advantage, I want PEACE. He disrespected the United States of America in its cherished Oval Office. He can come back when he is ready for Peace.”

The White House later dispatched Senator Lindsey Graham to tell reporters that Zelensky should consider stepping down.

“The president’s verbal assault on Mr. Zelensky was a stunning display of anger and resentment toward the leader of a country that has been invaded by a larger power intent on eliminating it as an independent state. No other president in memory has lashed out at a visiting foreign leader in the Oval Office on camera in such a vituperative way, not even at an adversary of the United States, much less a putative ally.”

For those of us with English degrees who don’t know what the word “vituperative” means:

As in; “I’m gonna have to get vituperative on yo ‘ass.”

This story really is a ripper:

“The spectacle underlined how radically Mr. Trump has reoriented American foreign policy in less than six weeks back in office, all but switching sides in the war in Europe as he expresses sympathy for President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia and antipathy for Mr. Zelensky.

Even as he shouted at the Ukrainian leader in the Oval Office, the president spoke of Mr. Putin as if they were friends, saying that the Russian leader has “been through a lot with me” in enduring the “Russia hoax,” referring to the investigation of Mr. Putin’s clandestine efforts to help Mr. Trump win the 2016 election.”

The confrontation obviously benefits Vladimir V. Putin. Former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev — who knows a thing about puppet leadership — had this to say on Twitter:

Meanwhile, the confrontation “deeply alarmed” European leaders:

“America’s traditional European allies, on the other hand, were deeply alarmed and rallied behind Mr. Zelensky, with the leaders of France, Germany, Poland and others issuing statements of support for Ukraine and its beleaguered leader. The show of solidarity came just days after the United States sided with Russia over Europe in opposing a U.N. resolution condemning Russian aggression on the third anniversary of its full-fledged invasion of Ukraine.”

There’s a real question about whether this was planned for the cameras. If it was planned, then Trump is possibly more strategic than we give him credit for. If it was unplanned, then it shows the leader of the free world can blow up a peace process because of his bad temper.

“Mr. Vance’s eagerness to assail Mr. Zelensky raised the question of whether it was a planned or impromptu ambush. Mr. Vance has never been a supporter of Ukraine and said in 2022 that “I don’t really care what happens to Ukraine.””

And of course, there are consequences for all this:

After Mr. Vance began chastising Mr. Zelensky, it seemed to prompt Mr. Trump to join in. The result, though, was the blowup of an economic deal that Mr. Trump had prioritized in recent days, a commitment by Ukraine to turn over rare mineral rights to repay U.S. military aid over the past three years. The future of that deal remained unclear. A Trump administration official said later on Friday that all U.S. aid to Ukraine could be canceled imminently.

People are also wondering how Senator Graham and Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, once fierce backers of Ukraine, can have turned so spectacularly around.

“It was a measure of how much Republicans have fallen behind Mr. Trump that Mr. Graham and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, both onetime hawks and strong supporters of Ukraine against Russia, backed the president and vice president.”

I don’t know. Perhaps it’s because they’re what I like to call “piss men?”

During the Oval Office blowup, Vance repeatedly asked Zelenskyy to “say thank you” for U.S. assistance, as if he were lecturing a child.

“Mr. Zelensky tried to respond to Mr. Vance’s assertions and said that the United States could feel threatened by Russia some day. “You have a nice ocean and don’t feel now, but you will feel it in the future,” he said.

That set off Mr. Trump, who cut off Mr. Zelensky. “Don’t tell us what we’re going to feel,” he said, raising his voice. “You’re not in a good position. You don’t have the cards right now.”

“I’m not playing cards,” Mr. Zelensky replied. “I’m very serious, Mr. President. I’m the president in a war.””

Burrrrrn.

Democrats, who as we know, lost the recent elections and yet respected the outcome in a democracy, slammed Trump.

Not only the Dems. Also the “presidents and prime ministers of France, Germany, Norway, Sweden, the Netherlands, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Poland, Spain, the Czech Republic, Moldova, Portugal, Finland, Iceland, Ireland, Luxembourg and others.”

That’s a lot of presidents and prime ministers! Even the new leader of Germany, who recently survived U.S. efforts to support Nazis in the elections against him:

“We stand with Ukraine in good and in testing times,” wrote Friedrich Merz, set to be Germany’s next chancellor after elections this week. “We must never confuse aggressor and victim in this terrible war.”

The same reporter, Peter Baker, also makes it clear that…

In Showdown With Zelensky, Trump Takes Offense on Putin’s Behalf

This is in an analysis piece on the paper’s website. It’s also reassuring to see the memes proliferating in response, this morning:

“A few moments later, Mr. Zelensky again cited Mr. Putin’s role in the war and suggested that Mr. Trump was listening to the Russian leader too much. In response to Mr. Trump’s comment that Ukrainian cities were destroyed, Mr. Zelensky said no, they had survived despite Russian bombardment.

“Maybe it’s Putin who’s sharing this disinformation that he destroyed us,” Mr. Zelensky said.

Mr. Trump came to Mr. Putin’s defense. “He had to suffer through the Russia hoax,” he said, referring to the investigation during his first term into Russian interference on Mr. Trump’s behalf during the 2016 election. “I think that he wants to make a deal and he’d like to see an end.”

Of course, the Russia “hoax” was no hoax.

“In fact, the investigation by the special counsel Robert S. Mueller III was no hoax and concluded definitively that Mr. Putin ordered an intelligence operation to tilt the election eight years ago to Mr. Trump. Although Mr. Mueller said in his final report in 2019 that “the evidence was not sufficient to support criminal charges,” he made clear that Mr. Trump’s campaign benefited from Russian assistance.”

This second piece by Baker, which doesn’t feature in today’s paper version of the Times, presumably because it only got published late after the presses rolled, is absolutely damning of Trump. It is remarkable. Almost vituperative, albeit too low-key for that.

“But what was particularly striking in their exchange was how much Mr. Trump seemed insulted on Mr. Putin’s behalf. He has long been an open admirer of Mr. Putin and has rarely offered any criticism of his own. Just this week, he called Mr. Putin “smart” and “cunning,” and declined to call him a dictator even after calling Mr. Zelensky that.

“You want me to say really terrible things about Putin and then say, ‘Hi, Vladimir, how are we doing on the deal?’” Mr. Trump told Mr. Zelensky on Friday. “It doesn’t work that way.””

It portrays Trump as like a confused child trying to defend a bully he is hoping to endear himself to:

“He did not explain why it was OK to say terrible things to Mr. Zelensky while pursuing a deal. Instead, he portrayed the Ukrainian leader as unreasonably distrustful of Mr. Putin, who has broken multiple agreements guaranteeing Ukrainian sovereignty and calling for cease-fires and now faces an international arrest warrant for war crimes.

“You see the hatred he’s got for Putin,” Mr. Trump said with a tone of indignation as cameras recorded the exchange. “It’s very tough for me to make a deal with that kind of hate. He’s got tremendous hatred. And I understand that. But I can tell you the other side’s not exactly in love with him either.”

He came back to Mr. Putin and the Russia investigation again near the end of the session, describing the Russian leader as if they had bonded through a shared ordeal. “Putin went through a hell of a lot with me,” Mr. Trump said. “He went through a phony witch hunt where they used him and Russia, Russia, Russia, Russia.”

The affront to Mr. Putin seemed to stick with Mr. Trump. By evening, hours after tossing Mr. Zelensky out of the White House, Mr. Trump stopped to talk with reporters as he left for a weekend in Florida and again outlined his grievance with the Ukrainian president.

“He’s got to say, ‘I want to make peace,’” Mr. Trump said. “He doesn’t have to stand there and say about, ‘Putin this, Putin that,’ all negative things. He’s got to say, ‘I want to make peace.’””

It’s unbelievable and pathetic, and I am so sad that the leader of this country is so far out of his depth on the world stage. The idea that he would have trouble with a world leader “expressing that kind of hate,” given his penchant for vituperative outbursts of his own, is the ultimate double standard. We’re watching a propaganda war play out through puppets. It’s very important that we talk to each other about it and resist the inevitable urge to turn away. Turning away is exactly what those who are behind all this (and by that, I mean Vladimir Putin) want from the people. It’s what enables them to do what they want.

Thanks for reading!

Matt Davis lives in Manhattan with his wife and kid.